We recently published Shira Musicant’s devastating “Boy Cries Out.”
Here, we ask her two questions about her story:
1) I love how “Boy” and “Mother,” “She” and “He” become such perfect descriptions of the characters as the story progresses. Lacking any agency outside of what the writer gives them, they are defined by their roles! Do you think the impression would be the same if you (or their writer) had given them names?
If the writer would have given them names, say James and Sally, they might have begun to have personalities and required some development. Without names, Boy and Mother are stand-ins for the roles they might play in a story: a mother, whether good or bad or indifferent; a child, mischievous or playful or deprived. Their specificity might have made their demise tragic for the characters.
But not naming the characters, and later erasing the roles these characters might have inhabited, the writer narrows his story and clarifies his theme. So, I also read into this that the loss of those roles in a story, as in life, has tragic elements.
Sitting with your question, I think of characters I have had to delete from stories for various reasons, often because they do not contribute or move the story forward. I am always a little sad about deleting them and I love the idea of writing a piece featuring some of those discarded characters. Imagine the dialogue! Thank you for sparking that idea with your question.
2) Though your story is about Boy, the writer’s story is about Mother, then Woman. Except, of course, it’s not — it’s about martinis and climbing into cars and “toppling” heels. Do you think the writer has any understanding of the characters he has created? Or is he simply propelling them through a plot/desire of his own?
I think propelling the plot forward is a good way to describe the reason for this writer’s decisions. He takes a minute to find the narrative he wants to write, and, in the process, he creates Boy and Mother. When he does find his story, the writer decides it is inconvenient for the woman to have a child, to be a mother, so he must delete both Mother and Boy.
The deletion itself could have been a story, and there are many about these kinds of erasures: divorce stories, abandonments, murders even. But this writer has a different vision and wants to tell a more prurient story.
So my story is about Boy, as you note in this question, and about the children who are erased for whatever reason.





